Does binding precedent always lead to fair and just outcomes?

decisions that would otherwise be binding precedent when those deci- sions are "clearly irreconcilable with the reasoning or theory of inter- vening higher ... Apr 25, 2023 ... Normally, decisions of a District Court of Appeal are not binding on lower courts outside of its jurisdiction, but there is a notable exception ... Oct 28, 2018 ... Binding precedents coming only from higher courts are meant to save the judge from the burden of looking into every past decision and deciding ... Feb 29, 2024 ... ... precedent of previous decisions. However, a court does not have to stand by a decision that is not binding precedent. Generally courts will ... binding precedent, perhaps because the Court has discretion- ary review, meaning that it can manage its caseload and its members will want each of their ... Nov 26, 2024 ... U.S. Supreme Court decisions are binding precedent on all other federal courts and all state courts on questions of constitutional ... Aug 26, 2024 ... Special prosecutor Jack Smith on Monday accused US District Judge Aileen Cannon of overlooking “binding Supreme Court precedent” when she decided to dismiss ... The reports of panels and the Appellate Body are not binding precedents for other disputes between the same parties on other matters or different parties on ... Apr 30, 2020 ... Courts are bound by the past decisions of courts of the same level. So for example the Court of Appeal is bound to follow earlier decisions of ... The judgment of the Full Bench is binding precedent as it expresses the collective opinion of the Court as such