Is the naturalistic fallacy simply a specific instance of a broader logical problem?

Jan 15, 2008 ... In response to the proposal justifying the morality of homosexual acts offered by Todd A. Salzman and Michael G. Lawler, this paper seeks to ... ... naturalistic fallacy valid as a matter of logic. The three systems he investigates are, the Standard Deontic logic, a Relevant Deontic logic, and Schotch ... Certain scholars wish to acquit St. Thomas Aquinas of the “illicit inference from facts to norms” commonly referred to as the naturalistic fallacy. Seeing in ... Apr 21, 2025 ... Moral judgments are objective in the sense that they are true or false independently of the feelings or beliefs of the individual. When the conclusion expresses what ought to be, based only on what is, or what ought not to be, based on what is not. This is very common. Many 'natural' things are also considered 'good', and this can bias our thinking; but naturalness itself doesn't make something good or bad. For instance murder ... Jun 2, 2011 ... Caldwell, Bruce and Reiss, Julian (2006) Hayek, logic, and the naturalistic fallacy. Journal of the History of Economic Thought, ... Nov 25, 2020 ... What is the Naturalistic Fallacy? I remember being in the beginning of my anthropology journey and hearing this phrase all the time. Mar 27, 2022 ... In other words, according to Moore, ethical or moral naturalism is the claim that the fact or property of being good is identical with some ... May 6, 2015 ... ... naturalistic-fallacy argument against the naturalized epistemology? I am interested in knowing some recent replies to "naturalistic" or "is ...