Should judges focus more on the underlying reasons and principles of previous decisions when applying precedent?

Feb 20, 2025 ... Every U.S. Court of Appeals is a different court regarding mandatory precedent (i.e., the 4th circuit does not bind the 9th circuit) except ... The judgment of the Full Bench is binding precedent as it expresses the collective opinion of the Court as such Binding precedent is a legal rule made by a higher court that lower courts must follow. When a higher court decides a case, it writes down its decision in a ... Binding precedent. Precedent that a court must abide by in its adjudication of a case. For example, a lower court is bound by the decision of a higher ... Feb 13, 2022 ... The published opinions of the Court are binding precedent until overruled by the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court has recognized that ... Talal Al-Azem argues for the existence of a madhhab-law tradition' of jurisprudence underpinning the four post-classical Sunni schools of law. Aug 26, 2024 ... Special prosecutor Jack Smith on Monday accused US District Judge Aileen Cannon of overlooking “binding Supreme Court precedent” when she decided to dismiss ... Feb 15, 2018 ... Binding precedent refers to case law that courts have to follow. For example, the decisions of the Supreme Court of the United States are ... What is Binding. Precedent? How, when, where, and why courts are obligated to follow decisions by other courts. Page 2. What is Stare Decisis? Stare Decisis is ... The modern doctrine of the binding force of judicial precedent only ... As well as the binding precedent discussed above, there is also persuasive ...