What is the role of the confidential comments to the editor?

May 1, 2009 ... A few things are paramount: a well-written and novel manuscript, an informed and unbiased editor, and constructive comments from peer reviewers. Referee Report – 1. Supporting documentation to be supplied. Applicant's full name. Address. Date of birth. Personal qualities. The above details are to be ... Had any cautions been issued to a) Individual Yes. No b) General. Yes. No. Was the Player ordered off further to the report of an Assistant Referee? REFEREE REPORT FORM. PLEASE NOTE THAT REFERENCES MUST ACCOMPANY APPLICATION FORMS. IN SEALED AND SIGNED ENVELOPES, AS APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE. CONSIDERED ... May 1, 2022 ... The “Referee's report” findings of fact and conclusions of law, signed by the referee. The three sentences are worded exactly the same in all three of the ... May 5, 2014 ... 1 Answer 1 ... Two years without a report or decision is certainly too long. But this happens sometimes for various reasons. The journals do not ... Confidential Academic Referee Report. Download. docx. 72 KB. Primary Sidebar. Home / ... Home / Document / Confidential Academic Referee Report. Page last ... Oct 9, 2024 ... Most likely, its used to confirm what you said. There is a 10% chance that they have two good candidates and they are using it to split the two. Jan 11, 2015 ... A set of guidelines for referees in preparing their reports and cover letters to journal editors. While our document is directed to anyone asked to review a ... Although you should be frank in your assessment of the paper in the confidential letter to the co-editor, it is important that the referee report itself is ...