What if a referee has suggestions for additional experiments or analyses that could strengthen the study?

I often felt that if referees more clearly understood the factors that make a paper publishable, they would organize the reports accordingly, making them more ... Referee Report: Title of the paper. Author's name. ∗. Date of report. 1 Overview. This should be a very short paragraph to give the editor an overview of the ... Here, we focus on the referee role: how to ensure that our reports are objective, constructive and helpful to both editors and authors. also briefly discuss the ... Detailed instructions for JFE referees, including report format details for referee reports. Apr 8, 2019 ... Cataloguer Fiona Callaghan finds hidden gems in the Referees' Reports, a cornerstone of the Royal Society's publishing process since 1831. ... referee report. Completion of a referee report takes approximately 15-45 minutes. The report can be accessed for up to 15 business days from the date of the ... 3 days ago ... If the referee did not recommend rejection of the manuscript, that implies they want action on their comments. I would respond to every ... Feb 15, 2025 ... IF the referee report of Bellingham saying 'f*ck you' is followed, he would face a 4+ game suspension — reports Marca ... Referee Report Form. Page 2. PART B. In the space allotted below, please provide details about the candidate's performance that support the ratings assessed ... What are my responsibilities? · In your online application, you will need to provide details of your two nominated referees · Ensure that your referees are ...