What if a referee has difficulty understanding the authors' arguments?

Feb 10, 2010 ... Writing a referee report · A general summary of the paper and the contribution it makes. You need to highlight here what is new and interesting ... Criteria for publication. To be published in Scientific Reports, a paper must be scientifically valid and technically sound in methodology and analysis. What are my responsibilities? · In your online application, you will need to provide details of your two nominated referees · Ensure that your referees are ... Abstract. Most scientists learn how to review papers by being thrown into the deep end of the pool: here's a paper, write a review. Perhaps this is not the best ... Although you should be frank in your assessment of the paper in the confidential letter to the co-editor, it is important that the referee report itself is ... Mar 31, 2025 ... In July 2024, Mr. Zauderer was appointed as a Referee to hear and report on a motion and cross-motion involving a series of discovery disputes ... ... referee report. Completion of a referee report takes approximately 15-45 minutes. The report can be accessed for up to 15 business days from the date of the ... To assist referees in completing the reports, U.S. Soccer Federation Referee Program Report Codes for Cautionable and Sending-Off Offenses are available. Use ... Official Referee Report form for all sanctioned USGAA games ... Referee Information ... Referee Name ... First ... Last ... Tournament Information ... Start Time ... HH ... MM. 3 days ago ... If the referee did not recommend rejection of the manuscript, that implies they want action on their comments. I would respond to every ...