What if a referee believes the sample size is inadequate?

The purpose of a referee report is to recommend to an editor whether a paper is suitable for publication or not, potentially after revision. Page 1. REFEREE REPORT. CONFIDENTIAL. For Admission to Postgraduate Studies. SECTION A: TO BE COMPLETED BY THE APPLICANT. Applicant's Name ... Confidential Academic Referee Report. Download. docx. 72 KB. Primary Sidebar. Home / ... Home / Document / Confidential Academic Referee Report. Page last ... Apr 22, 2024 ... If referee reports are used they must be obtained for all potentially suitable candidates. ... Where an adverse referee report is received, the ... ... referee reports by other referees, cover letters, editor reports... ... On the grounds of the referee report the editor will take the final decision ... To see this iframe, please enable JavaScript. Membership. Become a Member , opens in a new tab · Types of Memberships. Athletes. Meet the Team · Point Standings ... Referee Report Form. Page 2. PART B. In the space allotted below, please provide details about the candidate's performance that support the ratings assessed ... Jun 30, 2019 ... This post is my attempt to make the world a better place by giving some advice on peer review. I have written over 100 reports, and I would like to think I do ... Making revisions in response to referees' comments can be challenging and sometimes discouraging. A pragmatic step-by-step approach can help overcome barriers. Form to be completed by a referee. Please do not return this form to the applicant once complete. Return reports for International.