What if a referee believes the authors have overemphasized certain aspects of their findings?

Here, we focus on the referee role: how to ensure that our reports are objective, constructive and helpful to both editors and authors. also briefly discuss the ... To see this iframe, please enable JavaScript. Membership. Become a Member , opens in a new tab · Types of Memberships. Athletes. Meet the Team · Point Standings ... Responding to Referee Reports. These standard tips will help you respond effectively to a referee report. May 1, 2009 ... A few things are paramount: a well-written and novel manuscript, an informed and unbiased editor, and constructive comments from peer reviewers. The Referee prepares a written report containing findings and recommendations and sends the report to all parties. By law, the parties have 14 days after ... Feb 8, 2019 ... Firstly, referee reports will generally only be sought for those applicants who are competitive in the process following interview. So don't ... Page 1. REFEREE REPORT. CONFIDENTIAL. For Admission to Postgraduate Studies. SECTION A: TO BE COMPLETED BY THE APPLICANT. Applicant's Name ... Oct 9, 2024 ... Most likely, its used to confirm what you said. There is a 10% chance that they have two good candidates and they are using it to split the two. Referee Report. The applicant has named you as a referee in support of an application for an Australia Awards Scholarship supported by the Department of ... REFEREE'S REPORT – ADMISSION. INSTRUCTIONS TO APPLICANTS. Referee reports must be submitted to the Campus Office of Graduate Studies and Research in envelopes ...