What are some of the debates and controversies surrounding peer review?

Referee Report · Complete a US Soccer Referee Report to record the basic game data · Provide a clear, concise and factual account of what happened · Include all ... 2025 NPSL Supplementary Referee Report · Your Email Address · Your Phone Number* (required). Date of Game* (required). Home Team* (required). Away Team ... Jan 3, 2025 ... Vinicius was sent off for deliberately hitting an opponent in the head with force, without the ball being involved in the incident. Here, we focus on the referee role: how to ensure that our reports are objective, constructive and helpful to both editors and authors. also briefly discuss the ... Feb 19, 2021 ... I wrote a paper about Abel's sums. I sent it to John Riordan the author of the books “Combinatorial Identities” and “Combinatorial Analysis”. Mar 4, 2025 ... 11 tips for writing a referee report · 1. Personalise each letter · 2. Review the candidate's resume · 3. Discuss the report with the candidate. When filling out the referee game report to the left please fill in all information asked on both sheets and send your report with the Game Day Rosters ... Apr 22, 2024 ... If referee reports are used they must be obtained for all potentially suitable candidates. ... Where an adverse referee report is received, the ... Nov 21, 2019 ... The objective of a good referee report is to very briefly state whether and why the contribution is worthwhile (or not) to be published. Feb 15, 2025 ... The referee's report states: “In minute 40, the player Bellingham, Jude Victor William was sent off for the following reason: To speak to me, ...