How can a referee balance providing critical feedback with offering encouragement and support to the authors?

Jun 27, 2017 ... Referee report which I call as Letter of Recommendation (LoR) is, perhaps the most important part of your application, particularly if your ... Nov 29, 2018 ... Just try to be the best reviewer you can be. 1. Is the methodology correct? 2. Is the methodology new? 3. Is the contribution incremental or ... Feb 15, 2025 ... The referee's report states: “In minute 40, the player Bellingham, Jude Victor William was sent off for the following reason: To speak to me, ... Other Links. Tennessee State Soccer Association · United States Soccer Federation · Referee Report Dashboard. © Copyright 2020 - Greater Memphis Soccer ... Referee reports are an assessment method where supervisors or other people with direct personal knowledge of an applicant's skills, knowledge and/or ... Referee Report: Title of the paper. Author's name. ∗. Date of report. 1 Overview. This should be a very short paragraph to give the editor an overview of the ... We draw from our experience both as editors, authors and association representatives to provide a set of guidelines for referees in preparing their reports and ... The Referee prepares a written report containing findings and recommendations and sends the report to all parties. By law, the parties have 14 days after ... Detailed instructions for JFE referees, including report format details for referee reports. The most useful structure for a referee report is to order information from most important to least important, as is the case with most technical writing.